Choose your club

Vital Mobile

Vital Shop

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Walsall 3 - Exeter City 0

Banks's Stadium

17/10/09, 3pm

Attendance: 4,063

Exeter Well Beaten at Walsall

Exeter City were comprehensively beaten for the second time in a week, this time at Walsall.

The Saddlers opened the scoring against the run of play after half an hour of good play from the visitors, and from there on there was only going to be one winner. Steve Jones scored his second on the stroke of half time which left City a mountain to climb. And the impossible became just that when Richard Duffy got send off mid-way through the second half, before Troy Deeney rendered the last twenty minutes meaningless as a contest.

The Grecians have now lost five out of their seven matches away from St. James Park this season, and have put themselves under considerable pressure for the two upcoming home games against fellow promotion winners Wycombe and Brentford.

Paul Tisdale`s side had started well contrary to the slow burner approach employed thus far this campaign. City looked assured and composed on the ball, the home faithful not given the chance to break out of a deathly silence. The Grecian army were making all the noise, and the team backed up this optimism. Ryan Harley called Saddlers keeper Rene Gilmartin into action with a couple of speculative 30 yard efforts, and Stuart Fleetwood also found the target from just outside the box after cutting in from the left. But for all the neat triangular passes no clear cut chances inside the box were created.

City failed to take any advantage from their superior start, and they were made to pay when with their first goal bound effort of the game, Walsall scored. The Grecians were caught napping from a throw-in, and Darren Byfield delivered a low cross in from the left by-line, that was converted by Steve Jones. Jones could hardly miss from just outside the six yard box and he fired low past Andy Marriott. And as often happens, the goal changed the game. Walsall grew in confidence, and Byfield ensured the City fans knew what the score was as the two parties engaged in some (not so) friendly banter. Byfield nearly had the next laugh though, but he hooked a left foot volley just wide. The City fans thought a 1-0 deficit at the interval was bad enough, but within the three minutes of stoppage time, Jones broke from the centre of midfield, and when none of the Exeter backline felt obliged to close him down he had all the time he needed to deliver a smashing strike from 25 yards into the bottom left corner. City had conceded on the stroke of half time for the second game running to trail 2-0 at the break. The players looked shattered and there seemed no way back.

City started the second half relatively well, and their supporter`s entertained the thought that their team could get back into the game. However, Richard Duffy momentarily lost all sense of sanity when a blatant body check saw the former Welsh international scamper down the tunnel before the referee had chance to brandish him a second yellow. The fact that the foul was in the Walsall half says it all, and Duffy could easily have let the man past. If the game wasn`t over already, it was now, and Walsall quickly scored a third, when Troy Deeney broke through a high City backline despite the best efforts of Danny Seaborne, and finished expertly one on one past the helpless Marriott. And the saddlers came close to a fourth on a few other occasions as they enjoyed their lead and extra man. City could have scored a token consolation but the ball didn`t fall kindly in the box to substitutes Barry Corr and Richard Logan.

There is much to ponder on for Paul Tisdale, and he must get it right for the next two home matches, which become massively important even this early in the season. The City boss must strive to find a settled team, and the constant tinkering is not helping the team one iota. Never under Tisdale have City suffered two heavy defeats like this in succession. Until this January, he hadn`t even lost two league games on the bounce. That record is now history, and Tisdale faces two season defining games in the upcoming weeks.

Player Ratings


Andy Marriott 6

No chance for any of the goals. Kicking was sound.

Richard Duffy 3

Suicidal sending off

Matt Taylor 5

Danny Seaborne 5

Scott Golbourne 5

Alex Russell 4

Russell was no doubt a very good player in his prime, and he is technically sound, but he simply can't keep up with the riggers of League 1 football

Ryan Harley 5

Some superb early efforts from distance, but his delivery from corners was atrocious - virtually every ball finding Ince in the Walsall goal in the second half

Bertie Cozic 5

Failed to impose himself enough

Marcus Stewart 5

Adam Stansfield 6

Worked hard as always without being a great threat

Stuart Fleetwood 4

Needs to work alot harder to endear himself to the City faithful

Writer: Chris Cleaver Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Sunday October 18 2009

Time: 1:24PM

Lets FIFA10

Have Your Say

Click here to register an account

Recent Articles

Exeter Draw With Saints (Saturday February 6 2010)

Exeter Sign Troy on Pernament Deal (Monday February 1 2010)

Exeter Snatch Late Point at Dons (Saturday January 30 2010)

PREVIEW: Yeovil Town v Exeter City (Saturday January 23 2010)

PREVIEW: Exeter City v Leeds United (Saturday January 16 2010)

Exeter need to retain top performers (Saturday January 9 2010)

Norwich overcome Exeter test (Saturday January 9 2010)

Norwich v Exeter beats the weather (Saturday January 9 2010)

PREVIEW: Norwich City v Exeter City (Saturday January 9 2010)

Exeter sign midfielder Noble (Tuesday January 5 2010)

Big Mac Returns to Exeter (Tuesday January 5 2010)

Watson Loan Deal Falls Through (Tuesday January 5 2010)

The Year Ahead: Exeter City (Wednesday December 30 2009)

Exeter City v Leeds United: TICKETS (Wednesday December 30 2009)

Perryman: Exeter will be alright (Wednesday December 30 2009)

Exeter`s Superb Away Support (Tuesday December 29 2009)

Home Crowds @ Exeter City (Tuesday December 29 2009)

Tisdale: We deserved a winner (Monday December 28 2009)

Exeter held by Gillingham (Monday December 28 2009)

Vital Poll: Troy should stay at Exeter (Monday December 28 2009)

Opponents in Focus: GILLINGHAM @ Exeter (Monday December 28 2009)

Exeter's Frear stays at Tiverton (Monday December 28 2009)

Norwood extends Sutton loan from Exeter (Sunday December 27 2009)

PREVIEW: Exeter City v Gillingham (Sunday December 27 2009)

Saints Breeze Past Exeter (Sunday December 27 2009)

PREVIEW: Southamption v Exeter City (Saturday December 26 2009)

Vital Poll: Should Troy Stay at Exeter? (Monday December 21 2009)

Exeter battle to Southend win (Monday December 21 2009)

World Cup to come to Devon? (Wednesday December 16 2009)

Exeter lacklustre at Oldham (Sunday December 13 2009)

PREVIEW: Oldham Athletic v Exeter City (Saturday December 12 2009)

Exeter City named team of the year (Monday November 30 2009)

Exeter Attack: Stansfield or Fleetwood? (Monday November 30 2009)

How many points will Exeter get? (Monday November 30 2009)

PREVIEW: Exeter v Bristol Rovers (Monday November 30 2009)

Exeter Heartbroken at MK Dons (Saturday November 28 2009)

Exeter's McAllister in Barnet Loan Move (Saturday November 28 2009)

FA CUP: MK Dons v Exeter City (Saturday November 28 2009)

VITAL POLL: How many points for Exeter? (Wednesday November 25 2009)

Stansfield rescues point for Exeter (Wednesday November 25 2009)

PREVIEW: Exeter City v Milwall (Monday November 23 2009)

Stat-master: Stockport v Exeter (Friday November 20 2009)

Norwood in Sutton Loan Move (Friday November 20 2009)

Exeter at Stockport: A Supporters Guide (Friday November 20 2009)

PREVIEW: Stockport County v Exeter City (Friday November 20 2009)

Tully for Exeter right back slot (Sunday November 8 2009)

Exeter brush aside Nuneaton (Sunday November 8 2009)

PREVIEW: Nuneaton Town v Exeter City (Saturday November 7 2009)

Exeter City Reserves lose in Cardiff (Tuesday November 3 2009)

Noone returns to Plymouth from Exeter (Monday November 2 2009)

Jansson's extends Exeter loan (Monday November 2 2009)

Tisdale: A Professional Performance (Saturday October 31 2009)

Exeter brush aside The Bees (Saturday October 31 2009)

Exeter City 3 Brentford 0 (Saturday October 31 2009)

Tully: home form crucial (Friday October 30 2009)

PREVIEW: Exeter City v Brentford (Friday October 30 2009)

Watson wants first team chance (Thursday October 29 2009)

Exeter youngsters out of youth cup (Thursday October 29 2009)

Exeter Reserves Draw at Plymouth (Thursday October 29 2009)

Exeter keeper Jones in December return? (Tuesday October 27 2009)

Tisdale: We Were Outstanding (Sunday October 18 2009)

PREVIEW: Walsall v Exeter City (Friday October 16 2009)

Exeter City Reserves Beat Swansea (Wednesday October 14 2009)

Exeter hammered at Huddersfield (Tuesday October 13 2009)

PREVIEW: Huddersfield Town v Exeter City (Saturday October 10 2009)

Exeter Lose In JPT Shootout (Wednesday October 7 2009)

Poll Results: Where will Exeter finish? (Wednesday September 30 2009)

PREVIEW: Exeter City v Hartlepool United (Wednesday September 30 2009)

Logan rescues a point for Exeter (Wednesday September 30 2009)

PREVIEW: Exeter City v Swindon Town (Tuesday September 29 2009)

Q & A: Vital Swindon Interview (Monday September 28 2009)

Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll

Vital Members League (view all)

1. jordan057 2

League Results (view all)

Latest Results
Exeter 1 - 1 Southampton
MK Dons 1 - 1 Exeter
Exeter 2 - 3 Carlisle
Yeovil 2 - 1 Exeter
Exeter 2 - 0 Leeds Utd
Norwich 3 - 1 Exeter

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
15. Carlisle 28 8 10 10 -4 34
16. Hartlepool 30 8 8 14 -10 32
17. Southend 29 8 7 14 -9 31
18. Exeter 30 7 10 13 -11 31
19. Oldham 26 7 8 11 -9 29
20. Gillingham 29 7 8 14 -11 29
21. Brighton 28 7 8 13 -13 29

Breaking League News

Matchday Live - Bristol Rovers Vs Walsall
» Bristol Rovers : 09/02/2010 19:33:00
HTFC- Team Lineup at Brighton
» Huddersfield : 09/02/2010 19:25:00
HTFC - Matchday Live Brighton Vs Huddersfield Town
» Huddersfield : 09/02/2010 19:19:00
Askou and Spillane to face Ipswich
» Norwich : 09/02/2010 19:16:00
STFC: Town Line-Up Announced
» Swindon : 09/02/2010 19:04:00
County Turn Semi-Pro? Think Again..
» Stockport : 09/02/2010 16:30:00
Foley and Greulich Fire Reserves To Boro Win
» Hartlepool : 09/02/2010 16:20:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Should Troy Archibald Henville Stay?
Suggested By:
Yes 75%
No 25%
Get Adobe Flash player
as seen on newsnow.co.uk